Contemporary AI lacks the imagination to diverge or negate in science
How useful are AI-generated scientific ideas to the researchers who understand the underlying work? This study asks authors of recent preprints to evaluate model-generated hypotheses for novelty, feasibility, plausibility and willingness to adopt them. Its source corpus spans 121,640 preprints, predominantly in biology and medicine, with smaller chemistry and social-science contributions. The reported results compare the diversity of ideas from different model classes, show how scientific preferences vary, and examine whether automated evaluators can reproduce expert ratings. A reward model trained on those ratings is also evaluated. The accompanying editorial critique separates these findings from broader claims about scientific imagination. It examines the restricted disciplinary coverage, self-selected participation and the distinction between a relative shortage of explicit null hypotheses and their complete absence. It also asks what is lost when numerical judgments are retained without the reasons behind them. The publication offers a substantial case study of AI-assisted hypothesis generation and of the evidence needed to assess it.
Contemporary AI lacks the imagination to diverge or negate in science Leer más »